I also tried to request one certain toy. Needed only the frog. I was told no. They told me to place the order & hope to get the one we want. If we don't get the one we want, I was told I could return what was sent to the nearest Petco store and exchange it for the one I wanted. Only problem is that I can't find it in any store! Good luck!
answered 10 months ago
0out of0found this answer helpful.
No, most likely not. Petco normally selects one for you. Unless you buy it in the store and not online, you do not have much to say about the one you want. :)